A payment of $426 is easier to fit into a monthly budget than a payment of $495. Whether it is the better loan depends on what you have agreed to pay for that breathing room.
Take a hypothetical $25,000 auto loan at a fixed 7% annual interest rate, with equal monthly payments and no fees. Over 60 months, the payment is about $495.03 and total interest is about $4,701.80. Over 72 months, the payment falls to about $426.23, but total interest rises to about $5,688.21. The extra year saves roughly $69 a month and costs about $986 more in interest if both loans run to term. Actual contracts can differ because of payment timing, fees, and rounding.
Neither payment tells that story by itself.
First put both offers on the same footing
A loan comparison becomes confusing when the deal underneath it keeps moving. If one offer includes a larger down payment, a different trade allowance, or an added service contract, you are comparing more than borrowing costs.
Start with the amount financed. It should be clear how the vehicle price, taxes, fees, cash down, trade equity, and chosen products produce that balance. Once those figures match, compare the rate and term. When they cannot match, identify the reason and decide whether the difference is worth paying for.
APR helps because it expresses the annual cost of credit, including interest and certain required fees. The finance charge shows the scheduled dollar cost of borrowing. The total of payments shows how much the scheduled loan payments add up to. Those are useful figures to have together, especially when one offer has a noticeably lower payment.
Your budget is part of the comparison
It is perfectly reasonable to care about the monthly payment. You are the person who has to make it. A shorter loan that leaves you unable to handle ordinary expenses is a poor fit, even if its total interest is lower.
The useful conversation is about the choices available. Can a lower rate achieve the payment? Would a different vehicle do it? How much cash could you put down without leaving yourself short? If a longer term is the workable answer, how long do you expect to keep this car?
That last question matters. A buyer planning to replace the vehicle in three years should pay attention to the balance likely to remain then. A buyer planning to keep it well beyond the loan has a different decision.
Read the completed credit disclosures before signing. They should explain the offer you selected, including payment schedule and any prepayment terms. A payment can be comfortable and a loan can be competitive. The figures need to show you both.